My Journey as a Pastor

A woman dressed in a patterned blouse, denim vest, and wide-legged beige pants, standing on a stage at a podium, speaking with one hand raised. Musical instruments, music stands, and a microphone are visible on stage.

I serve those who are deconstructed, de-churched, or filled with doubt. Many people find their way to Stafford, Texas, into our building, up the stairs, and back into my corner office lined with bookshelves. Often, they arrive carrying the weight of church hurt, God wounds, or even spiritual abuse.

As they enter, a thought lingers in the back of their minds: Will this pastor be like the others?
They realize quickly I don’t fit the mold. “You’re so… blonde?” they might say, noticing my long eyelashes. If I had a dollar for every time an unsuspecting stranger remarked, “You don’t look like a pastor” upon learning of my vocation, I would be a wealthy woman. They also recognize that I don’t preach like the others. “You’re so… real. Like me, even. I love your stories…”

 Their feedback resonates deeply within me, echoing through the crevices of my heart. They describe my heart as soft, tender, and forward—maternal even. Motherhood has been my most profound teacher in my journey as a pastor. It is the place from which I lead. It’s a place where I nurture others while also experiencing my own wounds.

And there have been many wounds. I invite my congregants into my office to share theirs:

“Come and bring your wounds, and I’ll bring mine. Together, let’s listen.” Shhhhh… watch us heal and transform as we light the Christ candle, sit on the comfy white couch with the bright yellow pillows and take in all of those book shelves. Let’s sip our coffee and hear your story—the whole story, not just the polished, shiny parts, but also the dark and scary ones. You can bring those too, the parts you’ve never shared with another faith leader.

As we sit in my spacious office, surrounded by bookshelves, a treadmill under the desk, and a yoga mat leaning against the wall, I notice their questions lingering unspoken in their eyes. 

  • Is this pastor going to tell me to pray more, and my mental health will magically improve?

  • Is she going to encourage me to just “lay down” my doubt and simply have more faith?

  • Will she insist that I just repent and stop asking so many questions?


When they discover that the answer to these questions is a resounding no, they leave with something they didn’t have when they arrived: a renewed question about who God might be. 

What if God is not a cold, distant tyrant? What if maybe God isn’t orchestrating suffering in some divine chess game? Maybe God is not unmoved by my pain? Perhaps God is near—closer to me than my very breath. Maybe God is for my good, even more than I am. Maybe God is good, gentle, and inviting. This is the kind of pastor I strive to be- a shepherd, a spiritual guide, a co-laborer with Holy Spirit in leading people on the journey home, to themselves and to God. 

A panel of three people sitting on stools on a stage, engaging in a discussion or conversation. One person is speaking into a microphone, while the others listen. There are musical instruments and equipment behind them.
A woman with blonde braids, wearing a white cap with a red emblem, white t-shirt, and black pants, stands on a wooden stage holding a microphone and looks at a laptop, while several children sit in the foreground, facing her. The stage has a wooden wall with vertical planks and a window that lets in natural light.
Four people in costumes standing outside with houses and trees in the background. The first person is a woman in a pink princess dress and tiara holding a wand. The second person is a man in overalls, a straw hat, and a shirt with a sign that says "Farmer Fight". The third person is a woman in a blue and white gingham dress holding a small dog. The fourth person is a woman in black with a large witch hat and yellow rain boots.
A group of people standing on stage, engaged in a reading or performance. Four individuals, including three young people and one adult man, are at a music stand with sheets of paper. Candles are lit nearby, and microphones and musical equipment are visible in the background.
Kelly Edmiston, Bert Waggoner and  Jonita Fair-Payton at the Sugar Land Vineyard.

My first book Shame-Free Sex Talks comes out

July 7th 2026

Book cover for Shame-Free Sex Talks by Dr. Kelly Edmiston, a faith-based parenting book that helps families talk to children about sex, relationships, and emotional health from a spiritual perspective, featuring colorful abstract artwork and modern

Join my substack